LDS Q3. How were the keys of the priesthood maintained through the Reorganization and Joseph Smith III?

The phrase “keys of the priesthood” means the authority given to the priesthood by God to represent Him in all aspects of their life—Church, work, and family. With that authority comes the responsibility to perform all Church functions as God wants them to be done. When priesthood does this, God honors that work by blessing it with His Spirit. When priesthood fails to do this, God is not bound to honor that work. This is the meaning of the scripture, “I, the Lord, am bound when ye do what I say, but when ye do not what I say, ye have no promise” (RLDS DC 81:3b; see also LDS DC 82:10).

When God gives authority to the men of the priesthood to act on His behalf, the retention of that authority depends upon the actions of the priesthood. When Jesus was instructing His priesthood, He said, “If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross and follow me. And now for a man to take up his cross, is to deny himself all ungodliness, and every worldly lust, and keep my commandments” (Matthew 16:25–26, IV). In 2 John 1:9 (IV & KJV) it states, “Whosoever transgresseth, and abideth not in the doctrine of Christ, hath not God. He that abideth in the doctrine of Christ, he hath both the Father and the Son” (italics added). These two scriptures tell us that the priesthood only retains their authority from God to represent Him when they strive to keep His commandments in all aspects of their lives, and they teach and live the doctrine of Christ. If they fail to do either of these things, they lose their authority from Him.

As was shown in the answer to a previous question, Joseph Smith III was called by God to be the successor to Joseph Smith Jr. as the Prophet of the Church. Not only was he called of God, but he met the four qualifications that God stipulated for attaining that office. Thus, God bestowed upon him the mantle of his father, giving him all the keys of spiritual authority necessary to fulfill the office of his calling. Those of the Melchisedec Priesthood who also joined the Reorganization brought with them the authority received from the original Church, because they never lost their authority, They had been faithful to their callings and had sought to teach the fullness of the Gospel restored by God through His servant Joseph Smith Jr. Thus, the Reorganization received God’s authority to become His true Church. This was evidenced by the powerful Spirit of God resident within the Church. As God told Joseph Smith III in 1859, when he made inquiry as to which church to join, “The Saints reorganizing at Zarahemla and other places, is the only organized portion of the church accepted by me. I have given them my Spirit, and will continue to do so while they remain humble and faithful” (see Pamela Price, “Divine Guidance Led Joseph Smith III to Become Prophet of the Church”, see also RLDS History of the Church 3:263; italics added). In addition, at the April 6, 1853, conference of the independent branches, the Spirit of God was so strong that many of the elders knew that it was God’s will for them at that conference to reorganize the Church with all of the higher quorums except the First Presidency, because they had to wait on Joseph III’s acceptance of his calling. In the prayer service on the evening of April 7, the following spiritual manifestations occurred, which showed God’s acceptance for what they were doing. According to Jason Briggs:

It was at this meeting that [there was] an exhibition of power, light, and unity of spirit, above any ever before witnessed among us. Tongues were spoken and interpreted; hymns sung in tongues and the interpretation sung; prophecy and visions were exercised here for the first time to the writer. Many sang in tongues in perfect harmony at once, as though they constituted a well practiced choir. Angels appeared and were seen by some, and a testimony of their presence given by others affirming one of them to be the recording angel, who exhibited a partially unrolled parchment as an unfinished record upon which we were assured should be recorded the act we were called to perform in the reorganization of the church, confirmation of the foregoing revelation of the 20th of March, given, enjoining obedience to the same. The evident proofs of divine direction were so strong, that doubt disappeared, while the light was so clear to all that diversity of opinion ceased, and the whole people were truly of one heart and one soul (see “God Reorganizes His Church; RLDS History of the Church 3:213-226”; Apostle Jason W. Briggs, editor, The Messenger 2:21–22).

Thus, we see that God transferred the authoritative keys from His Church restored in 1830 under His Prophet, Joseph Smith Jr., to the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints under His Prophet Joseph Smith III. As promised in a revelation given to Joseph Smith Jr., “The priesthood hath remained, and must needs remain, through you and your lineage, until the restoration of all things spoken by the mouths of all the holy prophets since the world began” (RLDS DC 84:3b, see also LDS DC 86:10; italics added).